Shidduch Dating – What on EARTH do the labels mean???

A lot of “Frum” Jewish dating websites make an effort to determine ones Hashkafa. This can actually damage more than help. In any case, here’s Frumster’s description of this mad system of categorization:

We do not use these terms to make judgments about an individual’s observance, nor do we encourage categorization of people by “putting them in boxes”. Our intention is solely to facilitate searches for a potential spouse; as an individual’s religious outlook and practice are essential criteria in determining compatibility.

Because these terms may be understood differently across the Jewish world, we encourage singles to search across Hashkafas (Jewish outlooks/observance categories), and focus on objective measurements of observance – such as frequency of prayer, and type of dress.

Modern Orthodox Liberal
These tend to be individuals who are Shabbat and Kosher observant, but have a more “relaxed” or “open” approach to Halacha, sometimes accepting leniencies that are not accepted by those who espouse strict adherence to the dictates of the Halacha. Such individuals may, or may not be involved in regular and consistent Torah learning or prayer, although the general tendency is to be more “relaxed” in these areas as well. A commonality amongst this group is that they are open to secular activities such as bars, clubs, and movies.

Modern Orthodox Machmir
These tend to be individuals who strive to maintain a lifestyle according to the rules and guidelines of Halacha (Jewish law); often this is reflected in greater involvement in daily Torah learning and prayer. However, they are modern in the sense that they are not “Yeshivish” (see the next category) and readily engage in the secular world while leading an Orthodox observant life.

Yeshivish Modern
These tend to be individuals who identify more strongly with the Yeshivish-black-hat community, but feel that working in society is an essential part of their Judaism. Such individuals strive to embrace a structured Torah lifestyle with a professional secular career. Identification with a “Yeshivish” outlook can reflect itself in dress, which Rabbi one follows, and the Torah institutions that one attends or supports.

Yeshivish Black Hat
With these individuals, Torah learning, prayer, and careful adherence to fulfillment of Mitzvos are core elements to a life of intensive religious commitment and spiritual growth. Strict and unbending loyalty to Halacha is seen as normative. Generally, an avoidance of the secular world is encouraged, and barriers are seen as critical to protecting against secular influences.

Hassidish
Such individuals embrace a Hasidic philosophy, which includes a commitment to the emotional/spiritual element of Torah observance. This can be reflected in an orientation in which additional emphasis is placed on prayer and fulfillment of Mitzvos with religious fervor and passion. Usually, there is a distinctive mode of Chassidic dress, which can vary according to the particular affiliation (e.g. Breslov, Ger, Lubavitch (Chabad), Satmar etc). Often, an individual follows and professes allegiance to a particular spiritual guide (Rebbe).

Carlebachian
These are individuals who are Shabbat and Kosher observant and tend to embrace a more spiritual, and relaxed observant lifestyle. This observant outlook emanates from followers of the late Rabbi Shlomo Carlbach who was an inspiration to many unaffiliated Jews in the 60’s and 70’s and who were drawn towards greater observance by a Rabbi who embraced a message of Torah, love of the Jewish people, and Israel, expressed through his own musicality.

Shomer Mitzvot
This category was created out of a demand for a no-name brand “Orthodox” category. Individuals who choose this category generally do not believe in labels or categorization.

 

The last category makes the most sense. The rest are just meant to confuse the h***l out of everyone else, as if they’re not confused enough about dating!

To quote Prof. Yitzchok Levine of the Stevens Institute of Technology:

“True, Modern Orthodox Machmir says that this category maintains “a lifestyle according to the rules and guidelines of Halacha (Jewish law),” and this certainly implies that one should be careful with bein Adom L’Chaveiro, but this is followed by “often this is reflected in greater involvement in daily Torah learning and prayer.” Why is there no mention of honesty, of care in not saying things that others find harmful, of visiting the sick, involvement in other chesed activities, etc.? One can, of course, ask the same questions about the other categories.

It looks like Frumster.com categorizes religious observance essentially by what a person does bein Adam L’Makom. But, as RSRH points out, five of the Aseres Ha Dibris are bein Adam L’Makom and five and bein Adom the Chaveiro and each tablet was the *same size*! Sadly, I think that this is the way many people think today, namely, that bein Adam L’ Makom is the most important aspect of religious observance.”

Personally, I find this all to be madness. Those that support this system, along with Shidduch resumes, etc. are devil incarnates IMO.

Comments

comments