The Vilna Gaon’s Theorem – Fact or Urban Legend?

In the Yeshiva world some people like to attribute the Vilna Gaon’s mathematical expertise (from his publication of a Trigonometry book Ayil Meshulash) and giving him credit to Cramer’s Theorem (his grandfather’s last name was Kremer, hence the derivative). I would like to debunk the bunk.

Firstly, while the Vilna Gaon wrote amendations and corrections on the Talmud based on Mathemics and likely was well-versed, the Ayil Meshulash book was a basic “intro” book to Trigonometry. Most high-school textbooks today cover much more (thanks, Reb Micha Berger) – see here.

Secondly, Cramer’s theorem/rule has two authors. Both were Gentiles, forget Rabbis with a secular name corresponding with Eliyahu.

  • Cramer’s Theorem (the result that if X and Y are independent real-valued random variables whose sum X + Y is a normal random variable, then both X and Y must be normal as well) has been attributed to Harald Cramer (September 25, 1893 – October 5, 1985), a Swedish statistician and probabilist, and
  • Cramer’s Rule (an explicit formula for the solution of a system of linear equations with as many equations as unknowns, valid whenever the system has a unique solution) was attributed to Gabriel Cramer (1704–1752).

This of course is not to say that the Vilna Gaon was not well-rounded in the Maths and Sciences. This is more of a matter of getting the facts straight.

Any questions?

 

This post was written by

Rafael (Rafi) Hecht – who has written posts on My Western Wall.
Rafi Hecht is a leading SEO Consultant and Web Programmer, employed full-time at iRISEmedia.com and currently residing in Toronto. He has been in the IT workforce since 2003, and has focused on Search Engine Optimization and Web programming since 2007. He also is a devoted husband and father. His personal blog can be found at http://blog.rafihecht.com.

Email